Skip to main content

Originally Posted by Rexi:
Originally Posted by Garage Joe:
Well I dunno really. I know that my cousin and I have been dreading this storyline. Two different deaths which I'm afraid still leave us feeling rather raw.
I was particularly annoyed by the gadjie who plays Roy describing how harrowing it all was for them. Not as harrowing as real life. Trust me on that.

Oh, i know Joe ... I am sure that it bought back memories for lots of people watching

 

The one thing that didn't ring true for me was that she seemed too 'well' to want to die right then. She'd been downstairs, lifted a baby, ironed a shirt. I just felt that she would want to go on for a bit longer. 

 

However, every time I expressed this opinion last night my friend who was watching it with me keep referring me back to the Hailey/Harold dilema.

 

I have no experience of that, so I conceded to the scriptwiters and thought they all made a cracking job of it.

I agree with your friend.   If it was the pain, she (the character) would have probably gone on a bit longer, but she knew she needed to increase the pain relief and didn't want to be 'out of it' and possibly back thinking she was Harold when she died.     I thought they did well and as I was reading (think it was in the Mail online) they didn't make it too mawkish an episode, like a Easties two hander - although I'm sure Julie and David could have done it well - but they showed life going on as normal all around the street in between scenes, and cut away after she'd started drinking the cocktail of drugs.  Made it all the more poignant I think.   

 

Joe 

Kaffs
Last edited by Kaffs

I've been thinking about the Hayley/Harold thing.

The way I see it, Hayley was always Hayley on the inside, and was only Harold on the outside. She could never 'return' to being Harold because he never really existed. However, I think she was frightened that she would become confused due to meds and relive the painful times when she was forced to live as Harold.

That makes sense in my head but I'm not so sure it makes sense in print.

Yogi19
Originally Posted by Yogi19:

I've been thinking about the Hayley/Harold thing.

The way I see it, Hayley was always Hayley on the inside, and was only Harold on the outside. She could never 'return' to being Harold because he never really existed. However, I think she was frightened that she would become confused due to meds and relive the painful times when she was forced to live as Harold.

That makes sense in my head but I'm not so sure it makes sense in print.

No, that's what I meant..  when her friend was dying she was talking about happy times with her husband, and Hayley didn't want to go back to a time in her life when she thought she was still 'Harold' on the outside and so unhappy. 

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Kaffs:
Originally Posted by Yogi19:

I've been thinking about the Hayley/Harold thing.

The way I see it, Hayley was always Hayley on the inside, and was only Harold on the outside. She could never 'return' to being Harold because he never really existed. However, I think she was frightened that she would become confused due to meds and relive the painful times when she was forced to live as Harold.

That makes sense in my head but I'm not so sure it makes sense in print.

No, that's what I meant..  when her friend was dying she was talking about happy times with her husband, and Hayley didn't want to go back to a time in her life when she thought she was still 'Harold' on the outside and so unhappy. 

 That's how I saw it too.

Yogi19
Originally Posted by Eugene's Lair:
Originally Posted by velvet donkey:

I never knew The Killing 1 was so long. 30 eps on DVD   

 

Utterly riveting.

 

Pretty sure Series 1 was 20 episodes.

Series 2 and 3 were 10 episodes each.

(Series 1 was actually 2 seasons, but they were run together on the BBC.)

Maybe the last ones are filler.

 

Five DVD'S and the first two are six eps each.

FM
Originally Posted by Garage Joe:
The killing was a groundbreaker, however I thought Borgen to be it's equal, and The Bridge better.

Agree with this comment but want to point out Spiral came first on UK TV I think. It was the worthy trailblazer for this type of foreign import. But I agree with Carport. The Bridge is the best of the lot.  

Xochi
Originally Posted by Garage Joe:
One other thing..... If I can post through these cogs and Danger Will Robinson messages.... We noted that House of Fools was on and I can now reveal that we managed about five minutes. I hate like hell to knock locals, but it really was sheight.

So bad I had to go and find the thread about it to say so.    Not a great fan of Vic Reeves at the best of times but have to confess he can be funny at times.   This was not one of those times.  

Kaffs

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×