Skip to main content

You know... we often say the law's an ass here - but aren't you glad we don't have the South African legal system?    The chief investigating officer in the case is due in court himself in a couple of months charged with several counts of murder?   Why is he still even working, never mind heading up a case like this.   His first testimony's already been proved to be a load of bollox.    I honestly don't know whether Pistorius is guilty or not and with developments so far, I'm not sure we ever will

Kaffs
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

You know... we often say the law's an ass here - but aren't you glad we don't have the South African legal system?    The chief investigating officer in the case is due in court himself in a couple of months charged with several counts of murder?   Why is he still even working, never mind heading up a case like this.   His first testimony's already been proved to be a load of bollox.    I honestly don't know whether Pistorius is guilty or not and with developments so far, I'm not sure we ever will

According to the BBC website, it is also alleged that the officer wasn't wearing protective clothing when looking over the crime scene; the "steroids" are in fact a herbal remedy used by lots of athletes; the officer claimed a witness heard the arguement between Oscar and Reeva from 600m away from the house but changed it to 300m, after a meal break. The officer also had to admit, when cross-examined by the defence, that there is nothing in the forensic evidence which disproves Oscar's version of events. 

Hmm, not sure what/who to believe.

Yogi19
Last edited by Yogi19
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:

You know... we often say the law's an ass here - but aren't you glad we don't have the South African legal system?    The chief investigating officer in the case is due in court himself in a couple of months charged with several counts of murder?   Why is he still even working, never mind heading up a case like this.   His first testimony's already been proved to be a load of bollox.    I honestly don't know whether Pistorius is guilty or not and with developments so far, I'm not sure we ever will

I was saying the same yesterday, this is like he's on trial already and not a Bail hearing, scary place 

Aimee
Originally Posted by moonie:
Originally Posted by kattymieoww:

It's a total circus,how they can select an impartial jury must be impossible.Reminds me of the showboating lawyers in American cases.

I dont think they use juries over there Katty.

No, I don't think so... all down to a judge.  In a country where policemen aren't even suspended when they're charged with murder 

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Garage Joe:
He had been cleared of attempted murder hadn't he. Then as soon as this bloke was accused of accidentally multiple shooting his g/f the copper was recharged. No prizes for guessing what result the corrupt SA government would prefer.

Really - I'll have to go and read up, I've only heard parts of it on the news.   What a country.

Kaffs
Originally Posted by Garage Joe:
He had been cleared of attempted murder hadn't he. Then as soon as this bloke was accused of accidentally multiple shooting his g/f the copper was recharged. No prizes for guessing what result the corrupt SA government would prefer.


I've got a dark feeling that old Pistol Pistorius will walk away scott free at the end of this.

Videostar
Originally Posted by Garage Joe:
He had been cleared of attempted murder hadn't he. Then as soon as this bloke was accused of accidentally multiple shooting his g/f the copper was recharged. No prizes for guessing what result the corrupt SA government would prefer.

According to this - http://www.guardian.co.uk/worl...tha-attempted-murder - the charges were dropped, but then reinstated 10 days before Pistorius shot Reeva.

Blizz'ard
Originally Posted by Videostar:

Couldn't Pistolrius just have checked first to see if he had an intruder, like...before he shot off his gun?

 

I would prefer to see what im shooting at before i wildly fire my gun.

Yes well... 

 

on a serious note - I'd like to think a bloke's first thought if he was getting up to shoot an intruder would be to make sure his gf was ok, tell her to stay where she was, or phone the police, rather than get out of bed without noticing she wasn't there.   Then again, if I got up for a wee in the middle of the night I probably wouldn't lock myself in the bathroom

Kaffs
Oh! ........ Sorry Lillibet! I will try to check my facts in future. (Entre nous, whilst I try to remain fair, I will be the first to admit that I am bigoted against the South African administration. I still boycott their produce and am of course a veteran sports protestor. Having said that, I notice that Steve Biko's ex-partner is attempting to start an anti-AN
Garage Joe
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Videostar:

Couldn't Pistolrius just have checked first to see if he had an intruder, like...before he shot off his gun?

 

I would prefer to see what im shooting at before i wildly fire my gun.

Yes well... 

 

on a serious note - I'd like to think a bloke's first thought if he was getting up to shoot an intruder would be to make sure his gf was ok, tell her to stay where she was, or phone the police, rather than get out of bed without noticing she wasn't there.   Then again, if I got up for a wee in the middle of the night I probably wouldn't lock myself in the bathroom

I was being serious, no one seems to be suggesting that it's a bit strange that he shot at someone he couldn't see, knowing his GF might be the one he could hear in the other room...no one in the press seems to be making that obvious point.

 

But yes, I agree with you.

Videostar
Originally Posted by Videostar:
 

I was being serious, no one seems to be suggesting that it's a bit strange that he shot at someone he couldn't see, knowing his GF might be the one he could hear in the other room...no one in the press seems to be making that obvious point.

 

But yes, I agree with you.

It does seem very odd

FM
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Videostar:

Couldn't Pistolrius just have checked first to see if he had an intruder, like...before he shot off his gun?

 

I would prefer to see what im shooting at before i wildly fire my gun.

Yes well... 

 

on a serious note - I'd like to think a bloke's first thought if he was getting up to shoot an intruder would be to make sure his gf was ok, tell her to stay where she was, or phone the police, rather than get out of bed without noticing she wasn't there.   Then again, if I got up for a wee in the middle of the night I probably wouldn't lock myself in the bathroom

Yeah Kaffs...locking the door? Does that add up?

FM
Originally Posted by Garage Joe:
He had been cleared of attempted murder hadn't he. Then as soon as this bloke was accused of accidentally multiple shooting his g/f the copper was recharged. No prizes for guessing what result the corrupt SA government would prefer.


No, he hadn't been cleared. It's just that the charge had been dropped. The charge was reinstated earlier this month, before Pistorius shot Reeva, so it's a puzzle as to why Botha was allowed anywhere near this case.

Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Videostar:

Couldn't Pistolrius just have checked first to see if he had an intruder, like...before he shot off his gun?

 

I would prefer to see what im shooting at before i wildly fire my gun.

Yes well... 

 

on a serious note - I'd like to think a bloke's first thought if he was getting up to shoot an intruder would be to make sure his gf was ok, tell her to stay where she was, or phone the police, rather than get out of bed without noticing she wasn't there.   Then again, if I got up for a wee in the middle of the night I probably wouldn't lock myself in the bathroom

My thought exactly Kaffy.

Moonie
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Videostar:

Couldn't Pistolrius just have checked first to see if he had an intruder, like...before he shot off his gun?

 

I would prefer to see what im shooting at before i wildly fire my gun.

Yes well... 

 

on a serious note - I'd like to think a bloke's first thought if he was getting up to shoot an intruder would be to make sure his gf was ok, tell her to stay where she was, or phone the police, rather than get out of bed without noticing she wasn't there.   Then again, if I got up for a wee in the middle of the night I probably wouldn't lock myself in the bathroom

Kaffy, I think he was already up and had gone out on the balcony - however it's still a bit strange that he 'assumed' that Reeva was still in bed. Surely it wouldn't have been that hard to check?

 

It's not as if getting up to go to the bathroom in the middle of the night/early hours is such a strange thing.

Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing

He got up from bed and he went to get a fan from the balcony(why? in the middle of the night he decided to do that who knows )thats when he heard the noise coming from the bathroom area and thought he had an intruder so he called out to the 'intruder'so why did his GF not answer that it was herself in the bathroom,his story doesn't make much sense.I also find it unusual that an intruder would lock themselves in your bathroom,if that's the way the intruder came into his house then surely the intruder would exit the house the same way when he heard the owner had been disturbed.The Bathroom was the only room that did not have window bars.

FM
Originally Posted by Extremely Fluffy Fluffy Thing:
Originally Posted by KaffyBaffy:
Originally Posted by Videostar:

Couldn't Pistolrius just have checked first to see if he had an intruder, like...before he shot off his gun?

 

I would prefer to see what im shooting at before i wildly fire my gun.

Yes well... 

 

on a serious note - I'd like to think a bloke's first thought if he was getting up to shoot an intruder would be to make sure his gf was ok, tell her to stay where she was, or phone the police, rather than get out of bed without noticing she wasn't there.   Then again, if I got up for a wee in the middle of the night I probably wouldn't lock myself in the bathroom

Kaffy, I think he was already up and had gone out on the balcony - however it's still a bit strange that he 'assumed' that Reeva was still in bed. Surely it wouldn't have been that hard to check?

 

It's not as if getting up to go to the bathroom in the middle of the night/early hours is such a strange thing.

Yeah, Fluffs - I'd read he'd been on the balcony too.   Even more reason, you'd think for him to have checked she was ok - not as if he woke up with a start and reacted without thinking.

Kaffs

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×