You are right Crunchy - they should have left her to last so she had no choice..

Also it would have gone to the public and Katie would have gone....

which is what Cowell knows so it does make you wonder.,...

But I am sure that this has happened before... a judge refusing to get rid of one of their acts... maybe Dannii or Sharon Osborne?  It must have been hard for her, but she really should have picked one.  But anyway, all the other 3 said treyC to go didnt they?  so it would have been her anyway.  Anyway she was in the bottom 2 like Katie, so what's the problem? 

It was a complete mess... and now that Cheryl has skipped the vote other judges will follow suit if it comes down to them having two of their own acts in the fireing line.

I was expecting them to go back to Cheryl after Louis and go to the public vote. It was a right mess.

Dannii saved Treyc..so it was 2-1 and Cheryls vote to make it deadlock like she said should have been taken out of her hands and done.

As O' Leary said, it's part of her job.
Fair enough, if he wasn't going to get an answer out of her he had to move on but like everyone else I can't understand why they didn't leave her til last?

It's no secret that I like Cheryl, but she's being paid probably loads of money to make these hard decisions. If a footballer refused to play a match, they'd either get sacked, transfer listed or severely disciplined and fined. She did it at judges houses so why couldn't she tonight?

Wasn't just her though. Who evers decision it was to tell Dermot to ask her 2nd made a big cock up as well.

Zackerly! (again)

It shouldn't have automatically gone to a majority vote just cos Miss prissy turd didn't want to do it. It should have gone to deadlock as that was prissy turd's choice.

Makes you wonder, if it was Matt and Rebecca standing there what would have happened?


Cheryl gets right on my baps, even more so this series. She signed a contract to do a job. Just cos she flutters her labia at Cowell does NOT make her the friggin messiah. Twunt!

 that me laugh out loud

Plus a brick through their window by their own fans...



And if its Liverpool, you would get robbed and your car tyres slashed

That made me laugh.


It's total bull shit like (Cowell wishes she did!), but it still made me laugh

It smacks of a fix...makes you wonder if thye knew Katie would go in a deadlock and wanted to keep her for publicity value.

Flutters her labia?  that's gross. 

You may be right Croc.  But I still like Katie better.  I am off now anyway.  Bye all

Have you got a video of that? I'd pay well to see it.

You'd be surprised at what goes on on the internet

Indeed... I had to actually search google images to find out what one was

Gutted for the paying voters who supported TrayC , by not going to deadlock they have been ignored.

If I was into women she'd be the last person I would want near my lils thank you very much!

Bet it didn't take long! Some people have no shame

How do you know? If you were into women you'd have different sexual taste to what you do now so she might be right up your street.

*tea everywhere*...

Karma you've made a lot of people lol with that line

Crunchy dear, I can appreciate beauty in a woman and have no problem saying 'she's got lovely hair or nice eyes or a nice figure' or whatever. But I know, without a shadow of a doubt, that I couldn't tolerate miss twee prissy knickers! She'd do my bleedin nut in.

You would though if you were that way inclined.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvs...ml?ito=feeds-newsxml

At least Malcolm McClaren left us with Never Mind The Bollocks  

Ever get the feeling....

...you've been conned  

Cheryl could have saved Treyc and let the public vote decide who stays, she didn't. She should be thrown off the panel. Having said that, since the rest of them conspired to get rid of the best singer in the competition to save one of the worst does it really matter anymore who goes and who stays?

It's no longer a singing competition, as is evident by that half-witted tool Louis forcing the likes of Jedward and Wanker on everyone and clapping his hands like an idiot proclaiming 'they are fun the kids will love them'. I'd happily shoot him in the head if I thought I could get away with it.

You'd have nightmares  

All that ketchup.

So Cheryl is being vilifed for not 'voting' to save TreyC and for allegedly allowing Katie to stay and making TreyC go?!   But it would have been OK if she had voted and KATIE had gone?  WTF? 


These two were BOTH in the bottom two: BOTH of them, so obviously BOTH of them are not the public faves.  Not just KATIE.  So why all the ranting about treyC going.   She was in the bottom TWO!  And it wasn't the first time...  So what the hell is with all the Katie hate and people whining about HORRID Cheryl getting rid of TreyC FFS?!  TreyC was in the BOTTOM two!  if people are so bummed out about her going; they should've voted for her.

Katie forgot her words ,she stopped singing the song and said sod it,she should have gone.
When you are in the sing off ,you are supposed to sing.

I see you're having another one of your mentalist fits. Treyc can sing, Katie can't. That's the outrage. Whether the public put her in the bottom two or not is irrelevant. You're talking about the same public who voted for Wanker and Mary the pub singer to stay in.

Maybe Erin, but TreyC's perfomance was shit.. she was all over the place and out of tune.  Embarrassingly bad.  Katie deserved to stay out of the two.  And I think all the Katie hate is pretty boring now.

Oh is a 'mentalist fit' a post that doesn't agree with what YOU think?  How predictable.  Another attack on me for having an opinion..  Shocker.  TreyC was shit and that is why she has gone.  get over it and deal with it and quit the personal attacks.

I think the outrage is more that Cheryl was adamant she wasn't voting either of them and wanted it to go to deadlock (when that is part of her job to vote for a contestant) and that it was automatically decided that it would go to majority vote between the other 3 judges, when in reality, Chery's vote or choice should have been taken into account.

How predictable. Another one of your attempts to play the victim. You always do this. You make a post foaming at the mouth and sounding absolutely livid then calm down and claim everyone's attacking you. You do this every single time.

Treyc can sing, Katie can't. It's as simple as that. They're supposed to keep the best singers in, they just kept in Katie who is only marginally better than Wagner and that really is saying something. You asked why people were outraged. I explained.

Fair enough Karma... I see it from that point of view... but i still like Katie better than TreyC.  Thanks for your post.. I am sick to death of putting opinions on here and getting told to piss off or being called mental or being told my posts are pathetic.  Its not that hard to put a different viewpoint across without personal attacks; some people could learn from you Karma.  I appreciate your posts.  Thank you. 

Prom if you don't like my posts then just ignore them for goodness sake.  Just get over yourself will you?  You know and I know for a fact that no matter whatever I say or don't say on here; I ALWAYS get attacked by you and another 3 or 4 people on here.   It's boring and predictable now....  give it a rest.

TrayC was shit ,but Katie forgot her words,for me that was it ,all over for her.
 

I don't think Katie will win because to keep appearing in the bottom 2 is not a good sign... but she still deserved to stay more than TreyC IMO.  She was just dull and crap tonight.  The right person left.