Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

quote:
Originally posted by JasmineJ:
quote:
Originally posted by RENTON:
Are people who wud do such terrible things less human than the rest of us? Or worth less? Lower class?


It's not rocket science - people who do such things have NO humanity, we aren’t talking less here, we are talking NONE whatsoever.


So shud they have less human rights? Or no rights??
Saint
quote:
Originally posted by RENTON:
quote:
Originally posted by JasmineJ:
quote:
Originally posted by RENTON:
Are people who wud do such terrible things less human than the rest of us? Or worth less? Lower class?


It's not rocket science - people who do such things have NO humanity, we aren’t talking less here, we are talking NONE whatsoever.


So shud they have less human rights? Or no rights??


Sub Human and no rights. Just put me in charge. Mad
Heartache
quote:
Originally posted by RENTON:
Are people who wud do such terrible things less human than the rest of us? Or worth less? Lower class?


That's a loaded question which is impossible to answer without qualifying the criteria for the terms used. 'Human', 'worth', 'class'...are you defining these by political, moral, social or cultural means?

I don't think you can lump an individual who performs such appalling acts as this into one 'catch all' group. Some people are mentally ill and have no control over their actions. Some people clearly just have no regard for life. In this case it is they who judge other people to be worth less than themselves.

This is a grown man who tortured and murdered one child and has inflicted the most appalling lifelong physical and mental damage on another.

I find it difficult to see why we should afford human rights to someone who has no regard for such things for others.
Queen of the High Teas
quote:
Originally posted by RENTON:
quote:
Originally posted by JasmineJ:
quote:
Originally posted by RENTON:
Are people who wud do such terrible things less human than the rest of us? Or worth less? Lower class?


It's not rocket science - people who do such things have NO humanity, we aren’t talking less here, we are talking NONE whatsoever.


So shud they have less human rights? Or no rights??


As far as I’m concerned you lose your human rights once you stop behaving like one.
J
quote:
Originally posted by katya:
Monsters/beasts like It have no rights at all. I would take It and kill It and harvest It for all organs (kidneys, heart, lungs,and eyes) I have a nephew on the transplant list waiting for a kidney and he could not care if it came from something like It. At least some good would come of this horror.


I fully understand the repulsion, sure we all do, but getting beyond that repulsion you realise that your proposal would make you a murderer?
J
quote:
Originally posted by katya:
Im sorry I get so het up over these things.I have 3 grand children 12 9 4 and they are my heartbeats. I know that by taking its life I would be classed as a murderer but what will they do to It. 10 years inside then out again to do god knows.


I know, I agree with your sentiment.
I think these people need to be contained for the rest of their lives; I’m not concerned with them being treated inhumanely in whatever place they are kept – so long as they never get the opportunity to harm another child that would be sufficient for me.
J

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×